Peer Review Process

Some policies in the review of Khazanah Hukum:

  1. Reviewers will review any submitted paper.
  2. Review process employs a double-blind review, which means that both the reviewer and author identities are concealed from the reviewers, and vice versa.
  3. In the review process, reviewers consider the correspondence of title, abstract, discussion (findings) and conclusions. Beside, reviewers also examine the novelty, scientific impact, and references used in the paper.

Submission Proses
Author Submit
Administrator Check (one week)
1. Maximum Turnitin Result 20%
2. Appropriate Scope (Legal in Human Right)
3. Journal Enclosure Style (APA 7th Edition)

Rejected or Sent to Editorial Board

Editorial board check (three to four weeks)
Checking the suitability of articles with four indicators: Articles that enter the review stage have at least 3-4 of the following elements

1. Change
2. Controversy
3. Trends
4. Emergency
Which is connected with the main theme of the journal, namely Legal in Human Right ( See Focus and Scope )

Rejected or Sent to Reviewer

Reviewer Stage (one until six months)
1. Blind Review
2. There are at least two reviewers
3. Editorial Board Stage (one to four weeks)
4. Assessment of the review results will be carried out by the editorial board

Rejected or Revision

Editorial Board dan Editor Advisory Stage (one to four weeks)
1. Assessment of the results of the Revision will be carried out by the editorial and advisory editors

Rejected or Sent to Editor in Chief
Editor In Chief (two to four Weeks)
1. Decide whether the article is accepted or rejected after receiving input from the Editorial Board and Advisory Editor.

Rejected or Sent to Administrator for Copy Edit and Proofread Stage

Copy Editing Stage (one week)
1. The author checks the article's final draft and completes the administrative requirements. Such as, sending Curriculum Vitae and Copy Right Agreement/Declaration Form
2. Proofreading Stage (one week)

Final check before publishing when a professional proofreader has proofread it

Publish