Plagiarism Policy

Syifa al-Qulub: Jurnal Studi Psikoterapi Sufistik is committed to maintaining the highest standards of academic integrity, research originality, and ethical scholarly publishing. The journal strictly prohibits plagiarism, inappropriate textual reproduction, redundant publication, and other forms of academic misconduct that compromise the originality and credibility of published research.

The Editorial Board recognizes plagiarism as a serious violation of publication ethics and has established this policy to prevent, identify, evaluate, and address plagiarism in manuscripts submitted for publication.

The journal uses Turnitin similarity detection software to examine submitted manuscripts and, where necessary, revised manuscripts and final versions prepared for publication.

The journal applies a maximum overall similarity threshold of 20% as an initial editorial screening criterion. However, similarity reports are evaluated carefully by the editorial team, as textual similarity does not automatically constitute plagiarism.

This policy is informed by the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and forms an integral part of the journal's commitment to originality, transparency, fairness, and responsible scholarly communication.

On This Page

  1. Definition and Scope of Plagiarism

  2. Similarity Screening and Assessment

  3. Levels of Plagiarism and Editorial Sanctions

  4. Author Responsibilities

  5. Investigation and Fair Assessment

  6. Plagiarism Identified After Publication

  7. Related Policies and Contact Information


1. Definition and Scope of Plagiarism

Plagiarism occurs when an author presents another person's words, ideas, research findings, data, arguments, or intellectual contributions as their own without appropriate acknowledgment or citation.

Syifa al-Qulub: Jurnal Studi Psikoterapi Sufistik considers plagiarism unacceptable in any form, regardless of whether it is intentional or results from inadequate citation practices.

Potential violations include:

  • Direct Plagiarism: Reproducing text from another source without quotation marks, appropriate citation, or acknowledgment.

  • Paraphrasing Plagiarism: Rewriting another author's ideas or arguments without proper attribution.

  • Mosaic Plagiarism: Combining phrases, sentences, or passages from multiple sources without appropriate acknowledgment.

  • Self-Plagiarism: Reusing substantial portions of an author's previously published work without appropriate citation or transparent disclosure.

  • Data and Idea Plagiarism: Presenting another researcher's original data, interpretations, theoretical concepts, or findings as one's own.

  • Source Misrepresentation: Providing inaccurate, misleading, or fabricated references to conceal the origins of borrowed material.

  • Redundant or Duplicate Publication: Submitting or publishing substantially the same research in more than one journal without appropriate disclosure and justification.

All authors must accurately acknowledge the scholarly works, classical texts, research materials, and intellectual contributions used in their manuscripts.

This requirement is particularly relevant to research involving Sufism, Sufistic psychotherapy, Islamic counseling, spiritual traditions, classical Islamic manuscripts, and interdisciplinary psychological studies, where accurate attribution of both primary and secondary sources is essential.

2. Similarity Screening and Assessment

All submitted manuscripts are subject to similarity screening using Turnitin before proceeding to external peer review.

The journal may conduct additional similarity assessments after substantial manuscript revision or before final publication when necessary.

The maximum permitted overall similarity index is 20%.

Manuscripts with similarity scores exceeding 20% may be returned to the authors for correction and resubmission or rejected when significant inappropriate textual overlap is established.

However, Turnitin similarity scores are not interpreted as definitive evidence of plagiarism.

Editors assess similarity reports by considering:

  • The nature, extent, and distribution of matched text.

  • The original sources of overlapping passages.

  • The accuracy and completeness of citations and quotations.

  • Similarity involving standard research terminology or commonly used methodological descriptions.

  • Overlap with the authors' previously published work.

  • The reproduction of original ideas, research findings, theoretical interpretations, or data without appropriate attribution.

  • The possible exclusion of bibliographic references and appropriately quoted materials when interpreting similarity results.

A similarity score below 20% does not automatically establish that a manuscript is free from plagiarism.

Likewise, a similarity score exceeding 20% does not automatically demonstrate intentional academic misconduct.

The editorial team reserves the right to request clarification, manuscript revision, additional documentation, or further investigation when originality concerns arise.

Similarity Assessment Principle: The 20% threshold serves as an editorial screening criterion. Final determinations of plagiarism are based on qualitative examination of the evidence, not solely on the numerical similarity index.

3. Levels of Plagiarism and Editorial Sanctions

Syifa al-Qulub: Jurnal Studi Psikoterapi Sufistik classifies plagiarism into three levels according to the nature, extent, and seriousness of the identified violation.

a. Minor Plagiarism

Definition

Minor plagiarism occurs when a limited portion of text from another publication is reproduced or inadequately paraphrased without proper acknowledgment, and the overlap does not involve substantial original research findings, data, or intellectual contributions.

Such cases may involve isolated citation errors, insufficient paraphrasing, or inappropriate reproduction of short textual passages.

Editorial Action

  • The editorial team issues a formal warning to the authors.

  • Authors are required to revise the affected passages and provide appropriate citations or quotations.

  • The revised manuscript may undergo additional similarity screening.

  • Further editorial consideration is subject to satisfactory correction of the identified issues.

Failure to address the concerns adequately may result in rejection of the manuscript.

b. Intermediate Plagiarism

Definition

Intermediate plagiarism occurs when a substantial portion of the manuscript reproduces another author's work without appropriate citation or acknowledgment.

This may include extensive unattributed textual overlap, systematic inappropriate paraphrasing, or substantial reproduction of published scholarly arguments.

Editorial Action

  • The submitted manuscript is rejected.

  • Following confirmation of the violation through an appropriate editorial assessment, the responsible authors may be prohibited from submitting new manuscripts to the journal for one year.

  • The editorial team documents the findings and the basis for the decision.

  • The authors are informed of the violation and the applicable sanction.

c. Severe Plagiarism

Definition

Severe plagiarism occurs when substantial parts of a manuscript reproduce another researcher's original findings, data, theoretical contributions, interpretations, or intellectual work without appropriate acknowledgment.

Severe plagiarism may also involve deliberate misrepresentation of the origins of substantial scholarly contributions.

Editorial Action

  • The manuscript is rejected.

  • Following confirmation of the violation through an appropriate editorial assessment, the responsible authors may be prohibited from submitting new manuscripts to the journal for five years.

  • The editorial team may refer the matter to the authors' affiliated institutions or relevant research integrity authorities when justified by the evidence and seriousness of the violation.

  • The findings and editorial actions are documented as part of the journal's research integrity records.

Application of Sanctions

Sanctions are determined according to the seriousness of the established misconduct, the available evidence, and the outcome of the editorial investigation.

Before imposing submission restrictions, the journal should provide the authors with an opportunity to respond to the concerns.

All authors share responsibility for the integrity of the submitted manuscript. However, the attribution of individual misconduct and any author-specific restrictions should take into account the available evidence and the respective responsibilities of the contributors.

4. Author Responsibilities

All authors submitting manuscripts to Syifa al-Qulub: Jurnal Studi Psikoterapi Sufistik are responsible for ensuring the originality, accuracy, and ethical integrity of their scholarly work.

Authors must:

  • Submit original manuscripts that have not been previously published or simultaneously submitted to another journal.

  • Properly acknowledge all sources of information, quotations, concepts, research findings, and intellectual contributions.

  • Apply the American Psychological Association (APA) Style, 7th edition, consistently throughout the manuscript.

  • Use quotation marks or other appropriate formatting when reproducing text directly from another source.

  • Clearly distinguish their original analyses and interpretations from ideas or findings obtained from existing literature.

  • Disclose previously disseminated manuscripts, preprints, or related publications where substantial overlap may exist.

  • Obtain appropriate permissions for copyrighted materials when necessary.

  • Cooperate with editorial requests for clarification, supporting documentation, or revisions concerning originality.

  • Ensure that all co-authors have reviewed and approved the final manuscript before submission.

The corresponding author is responsible for communicating originality concerns and editorial requests to all relevant co-authors.

The use of plagiarism detection software by authors before submission is encouraged but does not replace their responsibility to ensure proper attribution and academic integrity.

Authors should also consult the journal's Copyright Notice and Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement before submitting their manuscripts.

5. Investigation and Fair Assessment

Allegations or indications of plagiarism must be assessed carefully, consistently, and fairly.

When potential plagiarism is identified, the editorial team may undertake the following procedures:

a. Preliminary Assessment

The editor examines the similarity report, identifies the potentially problematic passages, and compares the manuscript with the relevant original sources.

b. Evaluation of Evidence

The editor considers the extent of overlap, adequacy of attribution, originality of the borrowed material, and possible impact on the manuscript's scholarly contribution.

c. Author Clarification

Where appropriate, the authors are informed of the concerns and given a reasonable opportunity to provide an explanation, supporting evidence, or corrections.

d. Editorial Determination

After reviewing the available evidence and author responses, the editor determines whether plagiarism has occurred and, if so, the appropriate level of violation and editorial action.

e. Communication of Decision

The editorial office informs the authors of the decision and its principal reasons.

f. Documentation

The journal maintains appropriate records of plagiarism assessments, author responses, editorial decisions, and imposed sanctions.

Where necessary, editors may consult the editorial board, independent experts, relevant institutional authorities, or applicable COPE guidance.

The journal distinguishes between inadvertent citation errors, inappropriate textual overlap, and serious research misconduct.

All investigations should be conducted with due regard for confidentiality, proportionality, procedural fairness, and the integrity of the scholarly record.

6. Plagiarism Identified After Publication

The journal recognizes that concerns regarding plagiarism may arise after an article has been published.

When credible evidence of plagiarism is identified in a published article, the editorial team will examine the allegations and determine the appropriate corrective action.

Depending on the seriousness of the violation, actions may include:

a. Publication of a Correction

A correction may be issued when the identified problem can be adequately addressed without invalidating the article's principal scholarly contribution.

b. Expression of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when substantial questions regarding the article's originality remain unresolved and further investigation is necessary.

c. Retraction

An article may be retracted when plagiarism substantially undermines its originality, reliability, or academic integrity.

A retraction notice should clearly identify the affected article and explain the reason for the retraction.

d. Institutional Notification

The journal may contact relevant institutions or research integrity bodies when serious misconduct requires additional investigation or institutional action.

Post-publication investigations and corrective measures should follow relevant principles outlined in the journal's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and applicable COPE guidance.

The journal is committed to maintaining transparency, academic accountability, and the reliability of its published scholarly record.

7. Related Policies and Contact Information

This Plagiarism Policy forms part of the journal's broader framework for ethical scholarly publishing and should be read together with the following policies:

Authors, reviewers, editors, and readers may report suspected plagiarism or request clarification about this policy by contacting the journal's editorial office.

Editorial Office

Syifa al-Qulub: Jurnal Studi Psikoterapi Sufistik

Department of Sufism and Psychotherapy, Faculty of Ushuluddin

Universitas Islam Negeri Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung, Indonesia

Email: syifalqulub@gmail.com

Contact the Editorial Office

This policy may be reviewed and updated periodically to reflect developments in research integrity, plagiarism detection practices, publication ethics, and recognized standards of scholarly publishing.